GMC Truck Forum banner

1 - 19 of 19 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
156 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Any studies done on different brands of oil filters or comparisons for use with synthetic oil (Mobil-1)?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
Consumer's Reports did one years ago - I don't know if it's been up dated or not. Delco was one of the high scorers, and I think Fram was low, but I don't remember the rest.

Here is a site that lists a lot of the physical dimensions of filters, but does not list the most critical information - filtration and flow properties. http://www.ntpog.org/reviews/filters/old_filters.shtml

It may be nice to know that filter "A" contains 120 square inches of filter material compared to 90 square inches for filter "B", but maybe "B" filters to 2 microns where "A" only goes to 10 microns. Filtration is what you should be concerned about - along with flow capabilities of course. A filter that traps particles 2 microns in size isn't much good if it can't pass enough oil through to satisfy the engine's lubrication requirements.

I use a by-pass set up made by Amsoil. It has one large filter that does the duty of normal filtration and a by-pass filter that filters particles down to 2 microns in size. The principle is pretty simple. The by-pass filter continously filters a smaller protion of the oil and takes about 45 minutes IIRC to filter the entire 12 quarts (I have a diesel). THe regular filter maintains the normal filtration process.

I am not endorsing Amsoil, but I am happy with the filtration system. There are other by-pass filtration systems available. Also, I use nothing but synthetic oil - typically Mobil 1 due to it's availability.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
156 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Consumer's Reports did one years ago - I don't know if it's been up dated or not. Delco was one of the high scorers, and I think Fram was low, but I don't remember the rest.

Here is a site that lists a lot of the physical dimensions of filters, but does not list the most critical information - filtration and flow properties. http://www.ntpog.org/reviews/filters/old_filters.shtml

It may be nice to know that filter "A" contains 120 square inches of filter material compared to 90 square inches for filter "B", but maybe "B" filters to 2 microns where "A" only goes to 10 microns. Filtration is what you should be concerned about - along with flow capabilities of course. A filter that traps particles 2 microns in size isn't much good if it can't pass enough oil through to satisfy the engine's lubrication requirements.

I use a by-pass set up made by Amsoil. It has one large filter that does the duty of normal filtration and a by-pass filter that filters particles down to 2 microns in size. The principle is pretty simple. The by-pass filter continously filters a smaller protion of the oil and takes about 45 minutes IIRC to filter the entire 12 quarts (I have a diesel). THe regular filter maintains the normal filtration process.

I am not endorsing Amsoil, but I am happy with the filtration system. There are other by-pass filtration systems available. Also, I use nothing but synthetic oil - typically Mobil 1 due to it's availability.
Thanks for the information and the links to interesting reading on oil filters.

I have been using Mobil-1 oil and AC Delco filters, so I guess, I'm not too bad off. I've always been concerned about the effectiveness of oil filters, since a few years back they seemed to get smaller, which in my mind would tend to go along with less flow and less filtration capability.
 

·
Suburbanite
Joined
·
597 Posts
Thanks for the information and the links to interesting reading on oil filters.

I have been using Mobil-1 oil and AC Delco filters, so I guess, I'm not too bad off. I've always been concerned about the effectiveness of oil filters, since a few years back they seemed to get smaller, which in my mind would tend to go along with less flow and less filtration capability.

Go check out(www.bobistheoilguy.com). There is a ton of info there about oil filters and almost anything to do with lubrication. I've been using Redline 10W-40 with an Amsoil Eao filter and its been working great so far although I think I'm going to switch to a Pure One, Wix or Baldwin as the Eao is a little expensive:D
 

·
[b]Not Prostreet[/b]
Joined
·
2,541 Posts
ams oil, mb1, k&n are the only ones that go into my truck... mb1 is my last choice though
 

·
HOT AIR BALLOON OWNER
Joined
·
14,932 Posts
Not another oil thread! lol Bob is The Oil Guy is the site for all the info.

AmsOil make great filters, Mobil, Puro, Champ labs, whatever. Just keep it clean and change it HOT with dino oil, syn you can push pretty far.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,868 Posts
I just tried out Royal Purple for the first time and haven't really been able to tell anything so far. It's been maybe 400 miles since the oil change but I don't know. I used a Mobil 1 filter with it. All together it cost me around $60 and as of now I'm not so sure it was worth it
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,525 Posts
your not gonna tell much of a difference, although if you ran an oil analysis i'm sure your engine would thank you for switching to a synthetic blend.

Dave
 

·
GMFS Uber-Member
Joined
·
688 Posts
I just tried out Royal Purple for the first time and haven't really been able to tell anything so far. It's been maybe 400 miles since the oil change but I don't know. I used a Mobil 1 filter with it. All together it cost me around $60 and as of now I'm not so sure it was worth it
If you bought the Royal Purple retail, I'm sorry to say, you were ripped off. $60 is a lot of money to be spending every three months just for the oil change, mine costs me roughly $23 and I'm using Mobil 1 full synthetic 5w30 and AC Delco filters, the big pre-shrink size (PF59 I think). If you scout eBay for a while you can find a GM dealer that gives decent deals, I got 12 filters for less than $40 shipped. And oil can be had for "less than retail" if you look...I get my Mobil for $20 a case, used to be $15 but my buddy had to raise prices. Any synthetic is the best way to go in my opinion, as long as it's really synthetic unlike that Castrol crap.

Please don't kill me for bashing money spending, I don't have much as a college student so I find deals wherever I can, but sometimes it's good to spend the money.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,868 Posts
No I agree that I got ripped off but I needed to change my oil and I was running out of time to do it easily because I had to go back to school and I don't have a lift or any of the toys that I have at work. I can get the oil through work for much cheaper as well as the oil filter but I couldn’t get everything to the shop before I had to go back to school. For 6 quarts of Royal Purple it was $48 and the oil filter was $9.99. Believe me when I tell you that I’m well aware that I got screwed. I was just running out of options. And from what everyone had told me about the almighty Royal Purple I was expecting a lot more than I received.
 

·
HOT AIR BALLOON OWNER
Joined
·
14,932 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,152 Posts
so basicly according to bob the oil guy we should all be using schaefers oil
 

·
My Dixie Wrecked
Joined
·
5,510 Posts
Wix filters, Valvoline oil
 

·
GM Trucks & UA
Joined
·
1,635 Posts
DSCN0676.jpg
What I use..
 
1 - 19 of 19 Posts
Top